Skip to content

Dinner, Itemized

Beef Steak Pie, 1796

What went into the pie, and what did those ingredients cost?

A beef steak pie with its pastry crust lifted to show beef, onion, and gravy

Lift the crust and there’s dinner. Slices of beef and white onion have cooked together with butter and a dusting of flour to turn the juices into gravy. The recipe comes from Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery, published in 1796. Here’s what we can put a price on.

What went into the pie

  • Beef

    11¢ for 2 pounds. The recorded price was 5½¢ a pound.

  • Butter

    About 4¢ for a quarter pound. The recorded price was 16.6¢ a pound.

  • Flour

    6.3¢ a pound. A dusting between the layers helps thicken the gravy.

  • Pepper

    $1 a pound. The pie only calls for a little.

  • White onion

    About $1 a bushel. Sliced between the layers of beef.

  • Homemade suet-and-butter crust

    Simmons rubbed suet into flour, moistened the dough with cream, then rolled in butter a little at a time.

Beef and butter About 15¢ combined

Butter cost about three times as much as beef by the pound. But the pie takes two pounds of beef and only a quarter-pound of butter, so the meat still takes the bigger share of the bill.

Sources 1796 prices, present-day West Virginia · Pittsburgh market, c. 1808 · Amelia Simmons, American Cookery (1796)

Make the pie

Jonathan Townsend cooks his adaptation in a Dutch oven over coals. He uses puff pastry as a modern shortcut and leaves the cooking liquid up to you. Water works, or you can try cider or beer.